What's new

Judge Dread (article)

Thread starter Admin #1

~Dr Juice~

Administrator
Joined
Jan 1, 1999
Messages
4,515
Likes
2,687
Location
Victoria B.C.
-- Article by Derrick Frainee, June 9th, 2015



Objectivity in bodybuilding, as well as its fitness related denominations, has been revered as an elusive quality and the single greatest flaw in achieving a stance of legitimacy amongst more established forms of competition. It is because of this that bodybuilding has yet to be identified as a sport by mainstream standards. Many bodybuilders, in fact, have a difficult time considering themselves true sportsman outside of the gym. The training aspect certainly aligns them with any other top professional athlete, but the lack of a well-defined scoring procedure renders bodybuilding ineligible of a “sport” designation. One could argue that bodybuilding is akin to other visually based competitions. Olympic diving, for example, requires a form of judging reliant on a keen eye instead of a concrete point-per-goal style system. Unlike bodybuilding, however, nobody is comparing who has the biggest cannon ball against who can make an insertion with the least splash. It’s this strange deviation where apples and oranges are permitted to exist side by side that becomes problematic. And like apples and oranges, sometimes decisions are made solely around whether the judging panel is in the mood for sweet or citrus.

With a disparity in size, shape, height, and conditioning, what factors are used to determine the worth of a bodybuilder? Bear in mind that this is not to be confused with the less diverse “physique” divisions, or far worse… bikini. Continuity among the judging at top level NPC and IFBB shows remains erratic at best. It seems the importance of the various criteria shifts with the ebb and flow of the officials’ personal preference. Unfortunately, subjectivity is a component of bodybuilding that can never be rid of in its entirety. However, there is no reason there should not be some level of consistency from show to show, right? A simple request surely, but how does one assess which qualities carry more significance? The question becomes considerably more complicated when looking at it from the angle that even the bodybuilding fan base can be wildly divided. The battle between Cedric and the likes of Branch for a podium spot is one of the best examples of contrast and controversy. Do you reward the freakish and battle-hardened body of Warren or hand it to the aesthetic and eye-pleasing build of McMillan? Well if you are Arnold you opt for the man best representing the “Golden Era.” On the same token, there are also circumstances where judging becomes stagnant and repetitive; a carbon copy of the show preceding it. Competitions immediately following the Olympia are notorious for rarely displaying a variation in the rankings despite a variation in the individual athletes’ overall package.

The dissatisfaction being displayed by both competitors and fans is understandable. Many would happily argue for a return to the more classic and aesthetically pleasing bodies seen from many of bodybuilding’s legends prior to the mass revolution of the mid-1990s. This is particularly true in light of the recent rise and frequency of deaths occurring among the athletes from this time period. In theory, it seems sensible to pursue a return to the glory days. In practice, it is far less feasible. The incredibly popular physique divisions exemplify the redundancy of such an endeavor. This relatively new classification more or less fulfills the needs of those wishing to maintain a less outlandish appearance while still remaining competitive. Initially, physique met this role quite well and has grown exponentially in the years following; to the extent that female bodybuilding has been all but replaced in its entirety. Even men’s bodybuilding has seen a reduction in participation as the majority of newcomers are now following the path to physique. Slowly but surely, however, the call of competition becomes an arms race, which has forced a gradual evolution away from physique’s original purpose. In a lineup that is largely harmonious, competitors will seek a means to stand out from their peers. Adding a little more muscle and becoming slightly more striated could edge out the competition. These changes will not be done in dramatic fashion; only just enough to become distinguishable. As more competitors partake in this with each passing show, the criteria for mass and conditioning escalates. The counterintuitive nature of rewarding lesser qualities prevents a cessation of this trend. In essence, it is the natural course of bodybuilding to push the boundaries of mass limitation. To revert this process is not only an exercise in futility, but it undermines the heart of the “sport.”
 

snowpatrol

Super Moderator
Joined
Nov 16, 2013
Messages
5,738
Likes
2,378
Location
Alberta
I've often said that about the MPD judging...started out ~5 years ago, "don't be too big/muscular/freaky" and the slow but sure arms race has guys like sadik looking like LHW bb's who threw on boardshorts & changed their posing routine
 
Joined
Dec 11, 2014
Messages
3,753
Likes
1,032
Location
Ottawa, Ontario
Great posting...

I'm so torn man...

I mean.. I'm looking at doing a show in 2017... my first one.. and I'm not too too worried about getting freaky lean... BUT I think my particular physique is more suited to physique then BB... That said... I don't have a fantastic hairline (or hair for that matter... lol) and freakishly boyish looks... The whole MP thing REALLY seems to play on the whole package.. along with the bling sorta deal... and that's not really me... BUT I'm also not quite large and filled out enough to do BB...

I guess I'll just train and GROW like a MF for 2 years and see where I'm at... :)
 

snowpatrol

Super Moderator
Joined
Nov 16, 2013
Messages
5,738
Likes
2,378
Location
Alberta
Great posting...

I'm so torn man...

I mean.. I'm looking at doing a show in 2017... my first one.. and I'm not too too worried about getting freaky lean... BUT I think my particular physique is more suited to physique then BB... That said... I don't have a fantastic hairline (or hair for that matter... lol) and freakishly boyish looks... The whole MP thing REALLY seems to play on the whole package.. along with the bling sorta deal... and that's not really me... BUT I'm also not quite large and filled out enough to do BB...

I guess I'll just train and GROW like a MF for 2 years and see where I'm at... :)
Will you be 40 by then? Masters' division physique competition (or even non-masters' at an amateur level) isn't particularly fierce
 
Joined
Jan 8, 2013
Messages
4,665
Likes
879
If you wanna be a bodybuilder then make that your goal and step on stage as a bodybuilder. If you're smaller than the biggest physique guy, so what? Do what you want to do and as time goes on, slowly build yourself closer to the ideal of that division. Having just returned from the OPA Provincials, trust me, there are MORE than enough physique guys. They couldn't fit them all on the stage.
 
Joined
Dec 11, 2014
Messages
3,753
Likes
1,032
Location
Ottawa, Ontario
Will you be 40 by then? Masters' division physique competition (or even non-masters' at an amateur level) isn't particularly fierce
Yea.... that's the idea... to hit up a masters show... you do Physique no? Should be good.... Thanks man... I'm gunna concentrate on putting on as MUCH MASS as I can from here until then... :)
 
Joined
Dec 11, 2014
Messages
3,753
Likes
1,032
Location
Ottawa, Ontario
If you wanna be a bodybuilder then make that your goal and step on stage as a bodybuilder. If you're smaller than the biggest physique guy, so what? Do what you want to do and as time goes on, slowly build yourself closer to the ideal of that division. Having just returned from the OPA Provincials, trust me, there are MORE than enough physique guys. They couldn't fit them all on the stage.
Fair.. apparently it's a real circus lately... everyone and there neighbour wants to 'compete' now... Are they all worthy physiques though or???
 
Last edited:

snowpatrol

Super Moderator
Joined
Nov 16, 2013
Messages
5,738
Likes
2,378
Location
Alberta
Yea.... that's the idea... to hit up a masters show... you do Physique no? Should be good.... Thanks man... I'm gunna concentrate on putting on as MUCH MASS as I can from here until then... :)
*Did*...bodybuilding now - it was always my intent, just didn't feel big enough yet

Great learning experience but I'm with MCS...if you don't fancy yourself as a physique guy then pursue bodybuilding, you don't have to win your first show...if you come in conditioned just be proud and build on that for next time

Almost the only time I think someone should hold off (at an amateur level) is if they mis-timed their prep and literally are going to be fat on stage.

Don't worry about the judging either...at least at first you're mainly competing against yourself
 
Joined
Jan 8, 2013
Messages
4,665
Likes
879
Well, it was Provincials so everyone looked fine. The difference though is the vast range of body types that the division showcases. From short, thick muscular guys with t-rex arms, to tall lean model-looking homos and everyone in between.
 
Top